So after this little intermission, here's my take on the original thread topic:
Some 2-3 months ago, a guy tried to spot a tune in this forum with a video showing maybe 2,000 people going mad at DC-10 to Charabia - Dachshund. Every freaking person was dancing to a track that most 'common' people simply don't understand and that is in no way mainstream taste.
The main DJ of the most successful party on the island (let it be ONE of the most successful partIES) - Marco Carola / Music On - is virtually unknown to people who are not into music over and above the mainstream stuff.
To me, just two examples of real and largely unspoilt Ibiza club culture that I hope will never die. It is maybe not the same like in the 80s, but still unique.
On the other hand, I also understand that for some, the existence of a cordoned VIP seating area may spoil the atmosphere. I personally find it amusing to observe people in the clubs that so obviously just went to Ibiza because they heard it's cool - to end up at this party getting the blast from the Funktion One sound system and looking like "Oh, that is totally not what I imagined...".
About the VIP table areas: I find most of them are deserted after a certain time either cause people go home (2AM - enough is enough!) or join people on the dancefloor.
What I personally find disgusting is venues like Ocean Beach that have nothing to do with Ibiza, but are rather a kind of 'spring break' locations. Went there last year for the first time, stayed 10min. The place was packed, all daybeds occupied, NOBODY dancing. What a boring and sad place, nothing to do with Ibiza.
Still, I believe there is much left of the Ibiza spirit even MTV was not able to destroy.
Btw, I am very thankful to David Guetta for keeping away the tourists from the prime parties. Also, thumbs up to the Tomorrowland team for channeling away a big part of the EDM crowd.