Oooh I'm loving this debate!
GazDaBomb said:
"I think" being exactly the point!
....I'd be interested to find out if you ever went to DC-10.
I remember when it used to be free, the toilets were scuzzy and it wasn't really known about but in the last few years, colourful flyers advertise the weekly lineups, mixmag write monthly reviews and annual cd compilations are released through high street outlets like HMV etc...and if I remember rightly, DC-10 was featured in a segment of the Ibiza coverage on the Big Breakfast complete with a Jo Mills interview.
They've even taken their established brand around the world as far as Australia!
...This is hardly underground is it?
So, if we track the DC-10 success story, we find a club which was created by clubbers for clubbers. It rose from the heart of the underground...just like a certain club you may have heard of called Space! (The terrace was a cellar where a dj used to spin records for the locals).
The atmosphere is always great in Ibiza (something we both agree on)...but this is all thanks to the Paradise Garage in New York, Amnesia in the early days and London clubs like Shoom.
I've got so used to corporate brands capitalising on house music and thankfully this doesn't seem to have dented the scene too much *phew*.
...However, if you kill the underground there will be no overground.
Without cutting edge clubs like DC-10, NastyDirty etc...what's to stop all the major clubs becoming like Eden?
After all, that's where club 18-30s people get told to go!
Any Thompsons holiday rep will reccomend mainstream places so what's to say that it won't be overrun with package holidaymakers more into t!ts, sunshine & "ENG-ER-LAND" than music?
The big clubs are all fantastic! But the atmospheres can only be sustained with a thriving underground scene which for the first time in ten years will not exist in Ibiza.
Orwell's 'Animal farm' springs to mind.
