As someone who has been into trance for around 20 years now, I'm satisfied that *this* is the problem the trance scene has. People like Above & Beyond still play trance, regardless of whether it's the exact type of trance you personally like. The trance scene had unfortunately become a bit of a joke in that respect - associtaed with people wearing rose-tinted glasses and harking back to days that are long gone.
In reality, this doesn't bear out - I've experienced good trance in Ibiza, the UK, at festivals, clubs, all sorts, from the early 00s to now. It's still a decent scene. But unfortunately the internet and the opinions posted on it have more power than they should. Despite the fact the vast majority of the complainers never go to actual events, and those that do are still good music-loving up-for-it people, trance had become the bastard child of dance music in many ways. The weird kid that stands in the corner at parties dressed in a gravy-stained 2003 ASOT t-shirt creeping people out. It's sad, and it shouldn't be that way, but it is.
I have high hopes that trance can continue to do well. The trance contingent across the globe, from fans to DJs, still do a fine job. But it's going to remain the outsider for now. Maybe people like Nina Kraviz and Sven Vath playing old trance tracks in techno sets is the sign things are going to change, but then our ASOT t-shirts friends complain loudly about that online too.
And if you think any DJ, let alone those who play trance, are "chasing the dollar" you're clueless. I could write an essay on this.
I'm sorry if that came across as a personal attack, I do not intend it like that, its just that your post is a handy example of what I'm talking about, but it has angered and saddened me for years the way trance had gained such a bad name from people moaning about "the way things are going" online.
Strange response. You are agreeing with most of my post!
I think I’ve probably been around the scene as long or longer than you. I’m far from clueless, you just have a different opinion on some themes. It does t make your opinion any more or less valid.
Reality is the trance sound is not doing well around the world. Record sales, volume of events and attendances prove that. Most djs will tell you the same, gigs are hard to come by even at the top end of the market. There is a scene but it’s relatively small. Ironically there is an arguenrnt to say that after being overly commercial it is moving to be underground.
A number of djs have disassociated themselves from the trance sound to pursue more money. They evolved their sound to something that has very little to do with trance at all - avb, a and b, oakie, emery, miller, loads more I could mention. I totally disagree with you re a and b - their sound has very little to do with trance to my ears. There comes a time when you bastardise a sound to such an extent it is no longer what it is packaged to be.
I was the one that said there is plenty of trancey sounds being played by the likes of Sven and Nina, you are just agreeing with that. Add in various other techno djs like klock, dettman, liebing and pan pot.
You can get as angry as you like. There is a lot of good trance still out there, much of it progressive. Barone, mundi, de Jong, ottaviani, solarstone, activa, orkidea, o’glue, joc, Templar, estiva, etc are just a few of the producers that are making and playing terrific music and there are many more including a number of old skoolers. There are still events but they are few and far between. Nowhere reflects that more than the uk and Ibiza.
Not sure what the Internet comments are about as its not something I mentioned. But while we are on the theme go and have a look on the anjunabeats forum, most know a and b sold out trance a long time ago. That’s got nothing to do with harking back to the old days, the old days were great for me but music has evolved and so have I. See you at dc10 and cocoon, I hope.