Hi PM.
I haven't been to Ibiza, but when I sought advice about my trip in 2019, most of the UK members seemed to like San Antonio a little more than Playa den Bossa. I didn't get an overwhelming American review; possibly because Britain will holiday in Ibiza, while we Americans (I'm from the US) would pay a heavier air fare and consider cruising or something domestic like Hawaii instead.
There are Americans who probably spend their spring break in Ibiza, but I think probably they're in the minority.
I think the main reason was mostly people had been to PdB previously, or possibly that PdB had gotten to be shabbier over time or was in need of renovation.
I was planning on staying at the Hard Rock Cafe in Ibiza, which is a nice place in PdB.
The other thing to consider is W in Eulalia.
Now $341 (Was $̶1̶,̶2̶2̶9̶) on Tripadvisor: W Ibiza, Santa Eulalia del Río. See 242 traveler reviews, 540 candid photos, and great deals for W Ibiza, ranked #23 of 321 hotels in Santa Eulalia del Río and rated 4 of 5 at Tripadvisor.
www.tripadvisor.com