X Factor

J

jessyg123

New Member
watched this on sunday.....

Few questions?

Why couldn't Kerry sing on a stool or something? Of course we all feel for her being in a wheelchair but it just looked wrong on that big stage.

How boring are the Macdonald Brothers? Dull with a capital D

How come Simon Cowel's copied the Amercian Idol format this year? The big stage and a 'superstar' singer on each week!

Really liked Eton Road, Ashley and Leona. :D
 
Ahhh here's a subject I like to talk about :D

Right... Kerry. Yes it's very tragic that she is in a wheelchair, but sorry she must have only got in the final for a pure sympathy vote. Her voice is just not as good as all the others. It's ok, but not recording contratc material. Plus when you are a pop star, you have to be able to hold the audience and entertain them. You can't do that in a wheelchair, sorry it's harsh but the truth.
Plus, I dont really like her anyway, whenever she "cries" there are never any tears!!! I think it's all an act and she really is playing for the sympathy vote.

The Macdonald brothers are a joke! What on earth is Louis doing putting them bland, boring singers in!! For one they arent even good looking so they wouldnt even get far as teen idols anyway, secondly their singing is sh1te! Talk about music to put you to sleep. Jessy you should re-play their performance if you still cant sleep! I predict they'll go next week.

I really like Eton Rd. Normal lads from Liverpool, each has their own style, and good voices!
 
Beckiboo said:
Ahhh here's a subject I like to talk about :D

Right... Kerry. Yes it's very tragic that she is in a wheelchair, but sorry she must have only got in the final for a pure sympathy vote. Her voice is just not as good as all the others. It's ok, but not recording contratc material. Plus when you are a pop star, you have to be able to hold the audience and entertain them. You can't do that in a wheelchair, sorry it's harsh but the truth.
Plus, I dont really like her anyway, whenever she "cries" there are never any tears!!! I think it's all an act and she really is playing for the sympathy vote.

The Macdonald brothers are a joke! What on earth is Louis doing putting them bland, boring singers in!! For one they arent even good looking so they wouldnt even get far as teen idols anyway, secondly their singing is sh1te! Talk about music to put you to sleep. Jessy you should re-play their performance if you still cant sleep! I predict they'll go next week.

I really like Eton Rd. Normal lads from Liverpool, each has their own style, and good voices!
Click to expand...

Thank god someone agrees with me about Kerry! I was starting to feel bad but I don't think she's a great singer AT ALL!!
 
Better still just cancel the entire show. The whole thing is a joke.

Walsh saying "I love your story" to the girl who lost her parent. What is there to love you mug.

Seems most people are not even judged on how they performe
 
I know, Louis does make some stupid comments. "I love your story" to a girl who's mum died recently before the show. Duuhhh!! Although that girl has proper milked her story, if that was me I wouldn't be banging on about it all the time just to get a sympathy vote :x
 
Beckiboo said:
I know, Louis does make some stupid comments. "I love your story" to a girl who's mum died recently before the show. Duuhhh!! Although that girl has proper milked her story, if that was me I wouldn't be banging on about it all the time just to get a sympathy vote :x
Click to expand...

I think thats a bit unfair its TV isn't it and after all she is only 17 and until you've lost a parent I don't think you can really comment on something like that.
 
jessyg123 said:
I think thats a bit unfair its TV isn't it and after all she is only 17 and until you've lost a parent I don't think you can really comment on something like that.
Click to expand...

But why keep telling the Nation? What has it got to do with her talent? The constant comments about it from people like Louis Walsh really commercialises it to be honest. It's just not something I would bring up on national television if that was me.

And as for not being able to comment on it until you've been in that situation, well you wouldnt know if I had or not would you!
 
Beckiboo said:
But why keep telling the Nation? What has it got to do with her talent? The constant comments about it from people like Louis Walsh really commercialises it to be honest. It's just not something I would bring up on national television if that was me.

And as for not being able to comment on it until you've been in that situation, well you wouldnt know if I had or not would you!
Click to expand...

Its the tv makers that latch on to something like that not the girl.. anyway I like her voice anyway so see past that.

No I wouldn't I suppose but from your response i'd guess you haven't but hey I could be wrong!
 
jessyg123 said:
Its the tv makers that latch on to something like that not the girl.. anyway I like her voice anyway so see past that.

No I wouldn't I suppose but from your response i'd guess you haven't but hey I could be wrong!
Click to expand...

But she obviously had a choice to tell the producers about it or not, she chose to do so and now it is mentioned before her performance every week.
I like her voice too, I dont think she'll win though because she's not as good as some of the others!
 
Beckiboo said:
But she obviously had a choice to tell the producers about it or not, she chose to do so and now it is mentioned before her performance every week.
I like her voice too, I dont think she'll win though because she's not as good as some of the others!
Click to expand...

I know anyway enough on that matter! :D

She won't win no think it'll be between Ben, Ashley and Leona.
 
jessyg123 said:
I know anyway enough on that matter! :D

She won't win no think it'll be between Ben, Ashley and Leona.
Click to expand...

Is Ben the guy whose ex-girlfriend found out he'd been cheating and put tuna in his piano, bleached his clothes and put glue in his lock? I love that story :lol: :lol:
 
i put £20 on kerry winning the whole thing.

i based it on michelle mcmanus got the fat vote, so she's gonna win by getting the disabled vote..

The longer she stays in the competition the harder it will be for people sitting at home to vote against her.. Thats my theory anyway :lol:

£140 coming my way :D
 
Beckiboo said:
I really like Eton Rd. Normal lads from Liverpool, each has their own style, and good voices!
Click to expand...

Normal except for the one that looks like Skeletor!! As Simon said, he is just odd.

p.s. You and Jon may get a chance to personally tell Louis your views on the 11th. ;)
 
spunkymonkey said:
Normal except for the one that looks like Skeletor!! As Simon said, he is just odd.

p.s. You and Jon may get a chance to personally tell Louis your views on the 11th. ;)
Click to expand...

you should not have said that, Bec will be practicing her singing for the next month:)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top